I'm not sure whether I will be doing this essay on Huxley or Baudrillard, but I already did a post about "Brave New World", so right now I'm going to talk about "Utopia Achieved". I both agree and disagree with Baudrillard on his views about America. He explains how although "Utopia" sounds appealing, and a perfect society is what America works for, what happens if we reach that goal? Nothing. It is understandable to have the "mindset" that Europe does. Which is, basically staying with what they got. Living a slow enjoyable, simple life. Europe may not be as modern and advanced as America is, but the high speed lifestyle of America sort of destroys a lot of people. Health is affected affected in many ways. From obesity due to fast food, to lack of sleep America has a lot of problems. And for what? To get better of course. Yet, why do we want to be "better" if we can't even have time to enjoy life while were living it? On the other hand, so far America has achieved a lot. So the current ideologies are working. Question is where do we stop before this country is driven into total madness?
I think it is interesting that when some people read Baudrillard's essay, it is not immediately clear to them that Baudrillard personally thinks the American way of life is not the smartest way of life. It is obvious that he believes that it is impossible to achieve utopia, which seems like a waste of time. This makes me wonder what Europeans think of Americans in present day. I didn't have to look far to find my answers. Like I have said in previous blogs, the Internet has made globalization and communication so much easier. There is proof of this on YouTube. I love YouTube, and one thing I notice about it is that a lot of comments on videos are in different languages. Another thing I notice is a lot of fights and prejudices. There are many comments made by Europeans that are make it seem like they are superior to Americans. Such as "stupid Americans", "American's are so fat and lazy", etc. This to me is strange because America is the country that as many people believe, has a superior ego. It is apparent that although we Americans may think we are "the best", Europeans may have the same ideologies about their own countries. And not just Europeans, mostly every culture and region out there has it's own sense of nationalism, as well as their own way of teaching history to favor their own nation. What I think I noticed about the Baudrillard, as well as the Internet, is that people will have always have their own opinions. So although globalization has increased and cultures are beginning to blend together more, different regions will always have their separate ideologies and approaches to a way of life.
Wednesday, March 7, 2012
Sunday, March 4, 2012
Film vs. Art
In class on Friday, we had a disscussion about Walter Benjamin's "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction". The main topic or argument of the conversation, was the difference between art and film. What is art? Does film "count" as art? When watching a film, how does the thought process differ from examining a work of art such as a painting? These are all great questions, and there is different answers for all of them. Benjamin disscusses how concentration and distraction work together or against each other to produce the meaning of art or film. The way class went on Friday can be used as an example of how these two work together. When the picture of the urinal was put on the screen, and the class was asked to decribe it, or explain the meaning of it, there was very little response. I myself was thinking, "Okay, I have no idea. You pee on it? I guess whoever put this in the museum was expressing his gratitude towards the sanitation system??". I really could not come up with any ideas worth noting, and I was racking my brain searching for a "legitimate" possible meaning for this piece of art. When I realized that there was nothing I could interpret, I said, "Screw it, it isn't even art. There is no meaning". Yet if there is controversy (art vs. not art), than it has to mean something right? Otherwise everyone would be in agreement that it definetly isn't art and there would be nothing to argue.
After discussing the urinal picture, we watched part of a Charlie Chaplin film. I found the film to be very entertaining, I liked it a lot. After watching it though, we disscussed our thoughts on it, and many people threw out different ideas right away. I didn't say anthing, but I agreed with some of the comments made. When Megan mentioned how fast our reactions to the film were compared to the urinal "artwork", I was sort of wonderstruck. I tried to think about what I had been thinking while viewing the film, and I can't really remember. I know that I was enjoying it, and that I was fully absorbed, momentarily forgetting my surroundings. Yet, in order to have opinions and ideas about the film afterward, I had to be carefully observing while watching it. Benjamin talks about how being distracted, can lead to better concentration which makes comprehension easier, yet it leaves everybody absent minded in the process. When viewing art, concentration can be harder because there is nothing to follow in front of you. No string of events to put together and form opinions. Just an object or a painting that you stare at, and it just stares back at you, almost mockingly. Everytime I look at a painting or something it seems to say : "hey, what do you think I mean? If you don't know or at least pretend to appreciate me, you will look dumb!", and it's so annoying. No, I'm not crazy. Paintings don't talk to me, but I do feel pressured when trying to interpret them, and my mind works hard searching for an answer. Because films are so leisurely, and enjoyable, it is much eaiser to come up with an opinion about them. When you are distracted it is easier to actually concentrate and feel some emotions toward what you are viewing. Needless to say, I like films better! And yeah, it's unfortunate that "cult value" is lost when the originality of art is replaced by easily replicated films and photos, but my thoughts don't really go that deep so I can't comment on that.
After discussing the urinal picture, we watched part of a Charlie Chaplin film. I found the film to be very entertaining, I liked it a lot. After watching it though, we disscussed our thoughts on it, and many people threw out different ideas right away. I didn't say anthing, but I agreed with some of the comments made. When Megan mentioned how fast our reactions to the film were compared to the urinal "artwork", I was sort of wonderstruck. I tried to think about what I had been thinking while viewing the film, and I can't really remember. I know that I was enjoying it, and that I was fully absorbed, momentarily forgetting my surroundings. Yet, in order to have opinions and ideas about the film afterward, I had to be carefully observing while watching it. Benjamin talks about how being distracted, can lead to better concentration which makes comprehension easier, yet it leaves everybody absent minded in the process. When viewing art, concentration can be harder because there is nothing to follow in front of you. No string of events to put together and form opinions. Just an object or a painting that you stare at, and it just stares back at you, almost mockingly. Everytime I look at a painting or something it seems to say : "hey, what do you think I mean? If you don't know or at least pretend to appreciate me, you will look dumb!", and it's so annoying. No, I'm not crazy. Paintings don't talk to me, but I do feel pressured when trying to interpret them, and my mind works hard searching for an answer. Because films are so leisurely, and enjoyable, it is much eaiser to come up with an opinion about them. When you are distracted it is easier to actually concentrate and feel some emotions toward what you are viewing. Needless to say, I like films better! And yeah, it's unfortunate that "cult value" is lost when the originality of art is replaced by easily replicated films and photos, but my thoughts don't really go that deep so I can't comment on that.
About Huxley
So, in class we were required to read Aldous Huxley's "Brave New World". We had a class disscussion, and it seemed that the class had come to a concensus that the world that Huxley described was "unethical". Why is that? A lot of responses to that question happened to be "because it's not natural". I was orginally agreeing with that statement, until I got to thinking about it. Exactly what is natural? Because as we learned earlier in the semester, lanuguage, knowlegde, and self-awarness isn't. Everything that we know is aparently a "myth" that was human created, so what is natural about that? Nothing.
"Community, Identity, Stability", is the motto of Huxley's "World State". It would seem obvious to most to say that the way the Conditioning Centre in the story creates these three things is not right. Creating hundreds of identical people, and predetermining thier role in society seems wrong, because that is not the natural way of things, the new humans are not given any choice. Although today's society is given more social mobility than those in the story, has it always been that way? What about the Caste system? Untouchables ring a bell? Where was the ideas of stabilty and communtiy and identity orginated? Communities may come together when the people involved have something in common, or are maybe working toward a common goal, but doesn't that leave those who don't fit the criteria out? Individual Indentity is very important in the United States, but what about those in places like China, where they don't really think of themselves as a unique individual, but as part of a system? Then there is stability, which may occur at times, and seem "natural". Yet, there is rises and falls of stability, and that all depends on the communication and cooperation of a community.
What I am trying to say here is that this land of Huxley's seems so appaling to us because of it's strict regualtion. Yet, all the goals of that community are the goals of our community. None of these three "goals" ever had a name, or an exisitence until humans gave them one...so does that make them natural or unatural? Im not sure...
"Community, Identity, Stability", is the motto of Huxley's "World State". It would seem obvious to most to say that the way the Conditioning Centre in the story creates these three things is not right. Creating hundreds of identical people, and predetermining thier role in society seems wrong, because that is not the natural way of things, the new humans are not given any choice. Although today's society is given more social mobility than those in the story, has it always been that way? What about the Caste system? Untouchables ring a bell? Where was the ideas of stabilty and communtiy and identity orginated? Communities may come together when the people involved have something in common, or are maybe working toward a common goal, but doesn't that leave those who don't fit the criteria out? Individual Indentity is very important in the United States, but what about those in places like China, where they don't really think of themselves as a unique individual, but as part of a system? Then there is stability, which may occur at times, and seem "natural". Yet, there is rises and falls of stability, and that all depends on the communication and cooperation of a community.
What I am trying to say here is that this land of Huxley's seems so appaling to us because of it's strict regualtion. Yet, all the goals of that community are the goals of our community. None of these three "goals" ever had a name, or an exisitence until humans gave them one...so does that make them natural or unatural? Im not sure...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)