Friday, February 24, 2012

Blog Post 1

So, this is sort of awkward, because I don't know what I'm doing. For all you experienced "bloggers" who look at this, don't laugh at me.

I guess I'm going to make this post about myths and stories, and all that good stuff. The language of myths, according to Barthes, is everything and nothing at the same time. People communicate, and relate to each other through myths. A myth can be something that the general public decides is important in life. For example, the "American Dream". The american dream is the common belief that anyone could be successful in their life no matter how bad the situation they are in. The belief that hard work will always pay off, and if someone is deserving, good fortune will eventually find them. This is a myth that most americans believe in, but does that make it true? Of course it doesn't. Because nothing is true. There is no such thing as truth. Language, science, religon, politics, they are all human creations. Humans are the only species that have developed systems so complex, and they are also the only species to even seek the "truth" out of something. Yet unfortunetly there is no truth to seek, because nothing is real. Nietzsche tries to explain this concept in the article "On Truth, Lies and the Nonmoral Sense". He argues that although humans know that they were the creators of language, they for some reason like to believe it is something that has always been. That a "tree" has always been a "tree". But as we mentioned in class, a tree doesn't call itself a tree, humans call it that. Humans also believe that the trees are here on earth for thier use and benefit. That in itself is a myth, because trees were here before us, and will most likely be here after us.
As we disscussed in class, in his article Nietzsche refers to humans as gnats. Implying that they are self-absorbed creatures that invented the idea of "knowing". Yet, ironically, he has to use the very concept of knowing which he is attempting to dismiss, to make the readers understand his arguement. His arguement would not make sense if there was not an unspoken agreement between humans of what a gnat is. We all know what a gnat is, and Nietzsche was counting on that to make his arguement. This to me is annoying. I understand the arguement that is being made about myths, language, and the truth, or shall I say non-truth; but I do not understand the point of arguing over it. Clearly,we can not simply go back before a time of language or technology and pretend it never existed, because language and "understanding" has to be used to even make this arguement. Therefore, I just find the whole idea of myths, and truth and language to be depressing. Because I too am a self-absorbed human, and I don't want to be told that I don't make sense because nothing is real. Fact of the matter is, humans do communicate, they do feel superior to everything on this planet, and this will probably never change until we do not exist anymore. I'm done with this now, because I'm getting angry with myself. Good talk. Peace out, fellow self-absorbed gnat-like creatures.

5 comments:

  1. I completely agree with your argument. I also wrote about this reading and put in something about the "American Dream". I like the way you went about discussing this reading. It is very interesting and it kept my attention. I was also confused and at the same time irritated trying to understand what exactly is the truth.. or more like what is not the truth. Everything is a lie.

    I did get annoyed reading this about lies and myths but at the same time I find it interesting. What would the world be if we never did invent these myths/lies that we all follow.

    I like how you brought up the idea Nietzsche referred to about us being self-absorbed . What if we are considered superior only in the minds of humans. I also stated in mine about different species being considered superior. What if in a monkey's mind they are superior. And the same thing in a dogs mind. We will truly never know who is superior in the world.

    Other species may see us as annoying bugs. We might be considered a gnat in the mind of a different species. Just like superiority... we will never know.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is true that Americans have believed in the so called "American Dream" for generations. In my opinion, I must disagree with the notion that the American Dream is a myth. I have watched countless people make something of themselves from practically nothing. Many celebrities have the "rags to riches" story to tell. This is when these celebrities go from having practically nothing to having it all. I definitely believe that people are what they make of themselves, but this is of course dependent upon how much hard work and dedication the individual puts in to make the connections necessary for reaching success.
    Current president of the United States of America Barack Obama has talked about the "American Dream" and has done so in depth. He has written a book titled "The Audacity of Hope: Thoughts on Reclaiming the American Dream" and obviously is a firm believer in this American Dream.
    Obama said in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, "If you're willing to put in the work, the idea is that you should be able to raise a family and own a home; not go bankrupt because you got sick, because you've got some health insurance that helps you deal with those difficult times; that you can send your kids to college; that you can put some money away for retirement". I sincerely agree with the views of the president.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can see how you would say that the notion of the "American Dream" is not a myth. I have also watched people who came from nothing become extremely successful. Where I disagree with the idea of the American Dream is that although it is possible for some, it is not possible for all. It depends on how hard a person is willing to work, as you said, but it also depends on the persons capabilities and situation. There are definetly celebrities who have gone from "rags to riches", but that is why they are celebrities; because not everyone can do that. If everybody was capable of becoming rich, there would be no poor, and we would have no reason to admire those who have made it, aka: celebrities. Yet even though it sounds like I am disagreeing with beleiving in the American Dream, I'm not. I think it's good for people to believe and have hope for a better life, because optimism will take people farther in thier life, if not as far as they had hoped, than pessimism would. I think it is important that our society has a little bit of false hope, because in the end it will take people farther in life.
      In pyschology this year, we talked about how people are born thinking they are a bit better at everything than they actually are. There was a study done that asked people to rate how good they thought they were at something (I can't remember what it was), and over 50% said they thought they would fall in the top 1%. This obviously cannot be true because only 1% can fall in the top 1%. Yet, it has also been found that people who lack this sense of self worth, are often people who become deprressed. So, beieving in one's capabilities is important.

      Delete
  3. Reading this reminds me of a paper I wrote last semester about the truth behind a photograph. It’s pretty much the same deal as a myth where something can be anything, but really nothing, and it is all based on interpretation. It’s confusing right?
    The meaning of a photograph is determined by how a person perceives it, and everyone has a different perspective outlook. Cameras simply capture our surrounding and create mirrors to our reality in a visual sense. But they do not show everything, only what is intended to be captured. This is where conflict between art and truth begins. This runs parallel to myth because they are both solely based on interpretation that is formed from historical relevance.
    However, the difference between the two is that the photo has a photographer who controls the outcome. How the picture is taken can influence interpretation. Photographers can manipulate how a photograph can be interpreted because of the way they take it. So in reality, the implication of a photograph may give off a completely different meaning from what it really it, thus telling/implying a lie. Haha does this make sense at all? It was just as confusing as Barthes reading.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is an awesome blog post, I couldn’t agree more with what you said. When I was younger, even just before this English 201 class, I always thought a myth was just something that wasn’t real. I used to believe that only things like non-fiction novels, and ghost stories were myths. After discussion in class, and reading this blog, I understand that there is a lot more myth than that. Everything around us; nature, inanimate objects, even living things are all considered myths. Have you ever thought about how things are named? Who came up with the word chair for a simple 4-legged object that you sit on? At first it seems like a simple concept, but think about it. We have a word for every single object known to mankind, and we haven’t seemed to run out. Other than naming things, how do they all catch on? Such strange words that catch on, and nobody questions it. Because everything is relative, nothing can be proven right. Although this is all true, I agree with you saying that there is no going back. If it were that problematic that we couldn’t answer why we promoted ourselves to naming everything, we still wouldn’t go back. We have to accept the fact that we live in a weird system, but that’s the way it’s going to be for a long time.

    ReplyDelete